Where Should You Form Your Business?

by | Feb 25, 2021 | Business

# Where Should You Form Your Business?

One of the first decisions you’ll make when starting a business is where to form it. If you’ve done any research, you’ve probably seen advice to incorporate in Delaware, Wyoming, or Nevada. Those states get a lot of attention for being “business-friendly,” and for good reason. But forming in a different state from where you actually operate isn’t always the right move.

For most small businesses, the best answer is simpler than you think. Here’s how to evaluate your options.

The Default: Form Where You Operate

For the majority of small businesses, you should form your company in the state where you live and do business. Here’s why:

  • You avoid foreign qualification costs. If you form in Delaware but operate in Texas, you’ll need to register as a “foreign entity” in Texas anyway. That means paying filing fees, maintaining a registered agent, and complying with annual requirements in both states, not just one.
  • You only deal with one set of rules. Every state has its own filing requirements, taxes, and compliance obligations. Operating in your home state keeps things simple.
  • It’s cheaper. Between dual registration fees, two registered agents, and two sets of annual filings, forming out of state can easily cost $500 to $1,000+ more per year than just forming at home.

If you’re a one-person consulting firm, a local retail business, or a small startup serving customers in your state, there’s usually no reason to form anywhere else.

When Forming Out of State Makes Sense

There are legitimate situations where forming in a different state is the right call:

Delaware

Delaware is the gold standard for corporations, especially those seeking venture capital or planning to go public. Over 60% of Fortune 500 companies are incorporated there. The reasons:

  • The Court of Chancery. Delaware has a specialized business court with judges (not juries) who are experts in corporate law. Disputes are resolved faster and more predictably.
  • Well-developed case law. Decades of corporate litigation have produced a body of law that gives businesses and their attorneys clear guidance on how disputes will be resolved.
  • Investor expectations. Most venture capital firms expect portfolio companies to be Delaware C-Corps. If you’re raising institutional capital, this is often a requirement, not a preference.

Delaware makes the most sense for: C-Corps seeking venture capital, companies planning an IPO, and businesses that want maximum legal predictability for corporate governance matters.

Wyoming

Wyoming has become popular with small business owners for its favorable LLC laws:

  • No state income tax. Wyoming doesn’t tax business income at the state level.
  • Strong asset protection. Wyoming’s LLC laws provide some of the strongest charging order protections in the country, making it harder for creditors to seize LLC membership interests.
  • Low fees. Annual report fees are among the lowest in the country.
  • Privacy. Wyoming doesn’t require public disclosure of LLC members.

Wyoming makes the most sense for: LLCs owned by non-U.S. residents, holding companies, and businesses where asset protection and privacy are priorities.

Nevada

Nevada is often mentioned alongside Delaware and Wyoming, but its advantages have narrowed over the years:

  • No state income tax. Like Wyoming, Nevada doesn’t tax business income.
  • No franchise tax for LLCs. But there is an annual business license fee ($200) and a commerce tax for businesses with Nevada gross revenue over $4 million.
  • Privacy protections. Nevada doesn’t require public disclosure of LLC members on formation documents.

Nevada makes the most sense for: Businesses actually operating in Nevada, and situations where the specific combination of no income tax and privacy is important.

Texas

Since many of our clients are based in Texas, it’s worth highlighting:

  • No state income tax. Texas doesn’t tax individual income.
  • Franchise tax. Texas has a franchise tax, but businesses with total revenue under $2.47 million owe nothing (you still must file the report).
  • Business-friendly environment. Texas has relatively low regulatory burden and straightforward LLC formation.

For Texas-based businesses, forming in Texas is almost always the right choice unless you have a specific reason to go elsewhere (like investor requirements for a Delaware C-Corp).

Utah

Utah is another state where we work with a lot of business owners, and it’s a great place to form:

  • Low filing costs. Utah’s annual report fee is just $18 online, one of the lowest in the country.
  • Simple compliance. Annual reports are due during your LLC’s anniversary month. File on time and you’re good.
  • Flat income tax. Utah has a flat state income tax rate, which keeps things predictable for pass-through LLCs.

Like Texas, if you’re operating in Utah, forming there is the straightforward choice. The low fees and simple process make it easy to stay in compliance.

I’m licensed in both Texas and Utah, so if you’re forming in either state and want help getting set up the right way, book a quick call.

Foreign Qualification: What It Means

If you form your business in one state but operate in another, you’ll need to “foreign qualify” in the state where you’re doing business. This means registering as a foreign entity with that state’s Secretary of State.

What triggers foreign qualification varies by state, but common triggers include:

  • Having a physical office or location in the state
  • Having employees working in the state
  • Holding inventory in the state
  • Having a significant amount of sales or customers in the state

Foreign qualification typically requires:

Domestication: Moving Your Business to Another State

If your business is already formed in one state and you want to move it to another, the process is called domestication. This is different from foreign qualification. Domestication actually transfers your company’s “home” state.

The general process:

  1. Confirm that both states (current and new) allow domestication
  2. Verify that your business name is available in the new state
  3. Obtain a certificate of good standing from your current state
  4. File domestication documents with the new state
  5. Dissolve your registration in the old state (do this last, after the new registration is complete)

Not all states allow domestication. If yours doesn’t, the alternative is to form a new entity in the target state and transfer assets, which is more complex and may have tax implications.

FAQs

Should I form my LLC in Delaware?

For most small businesses, no. Delaware’s advantages are primarily for C-Corps seeking venture capital or planning an IPO. If you’re forming an LLC and operating in one state, form in the state where you do business. Forming in Delaware while operating elsewhere means paying fees and maintaining compliance in two states.

What’s the cheapest state to form an LLC?

Formation costs vary, but some of the most affordable states include Kentucky (~$40 filing fee), Mississippi (~$50), and New Mexico (~$50). However, formation cost shouldn’t be the primary factor. If you don’t operate in that state, you’ll still need to foreign qualify in your home state, which adds costs that offset any savings.

Do I need a registered agent in every state where I do business?

Yes. Every state where your business is registered (whether as a domestic or foreign entity) requires a registered agent with a physical address in that state. You can serve as your own registered agent in your home state, or use a third-party service ($100 to $300 per year per state).

Can I move my LLC from one state to another?

Yes, through a process called domestication. Both states must allow it. The process involves filing with the new state and then dissolving in the old state. Not all states offer domestication, in which case you’d need to form a new entity and transfer assets.

What’s the difference between domestic and foreign registration?

Domestic registration is in the state where your business is formed (its “home” state). Foreign registration is in any additional state where your business operates. You need both if you do business across state lines.


Next Steps

For most small businesses, the right answer is to form where you operate. The out-of-state options are worth considering if you have specific needs around investor requirements, asset protection, or tax strategy. But the added complexity and cost of dual-state compliance isn’t worth it unless there’s a clear benefit.

If you’re not sure which state makes sense for your business, book a consultation and I can help you weigh the options. For a broader look at protecting your business, here is a quick overview of what IP protection costs as you get started.

Related Articles

Our Services

You Create,
We Protect

Lockhart IP provides legal counsel to entrepreneurs and creatives looking to build strong brands and protect their ideas and creative works.

Latest Insights

What Is My IP Worth? How Intellectual Property Is Valued

What Is My IP Worth? How Intellectual Property Is Valued

An investor leans across the table and asks, "So what's your IP actually worth?" You've got a patent or two, a trademark, maybe some trade secrets. You know they matter. But putting a dollar figure on something you can't hold in your hand feels impossible. Here's the...

Why a DIY Provisional Patent Application Can Backfire

Why a DIY Provisional Patent Application Can Backfire

True story: a founder came to me recently with what he thought was a simple request. He'd filed a provisional patent application on his own 10 months earlier on a product he had already started selling, and now wanted to convert to a full non-provisional patent...

Get in touch